India’s team management sparked debate on the opening day of the first Test against South Africa in Kolkata by leaving out promising young batter B. Sai Sudharsan from the playing XI. Sudharsan, who has been India’s preferred No. 3 since the England tour, was expected to continue in the role, but the decision to push Washington Sundar into that slot suggests a shift toward grooming a more flexible batting option who can contribute with both bat and ball.
Since making his debut earlier this year, Sudharsan has scored 273 runs in nine Test innings at an average of 30.33, registering two fifties and showing flashes of maturity at the crucial No. 3 position. However, his omission has not gone unnoticed, drawing criticism from former India stars, including Anil Kumble, who questioned the logic behind India’s four-spinner strategy for the Eden Gardens pitch.
ALSO READ: Ravichandran Ashwin Critiques Mohammed Siraj’s Opening Spell as India Fight Back In Kolkata
Speaking on JioHotstar, Anil Kumble said, “Really surprised at the line-up because I certainly expected Sai Sudharsan to be playing this Test match. Who’s going to bat at No. 3? Washington Sundar has been slotted there. Four spinners and two fast bowlers on a good Day 1 wicket is unusual. One of them will definitely be under-bowled.”
He also highlighted the added pressure on India’s new-ball pacers, given the spin-heavy attack. With the pitch offering little on the first day, Shubman Gill’s resource management will be closely watched.
ALSO READ: Rahul Dravid Once Lost His Cool: The Forgotten Clash With Allan Donald Revisited
Former opener Aakash Chopra echoed similar concerns, stating that India’s chosen combination could lead to limited game-time for at least one bowler. “Sai should’ve played this Test. India will be under-bowling at least one, if not two bowlers,” he wrote on X.
Sai should’ve played in this Test.
India will be under-bowling at least one if not two bowlers in this Test. #IndvSA— Aakash Chopra (@cricketaakash) November 14, 2025
In another post, Chopra questioned the long-term planning behind Sundar’s promotion, asking whether India sees him as their overseas No. 3 as well. “India have tried seven different batters at No. 3 since Pujara left that spot,” he pointed out, highlighting the ongoing uncertainty around the position.
