The pitch debate from the opening Test between India and South Africa at Eden Gardens has sparked considerable discussion, especially after head coach Gautam Gambhir confirmed that the Indian team had indeed requested a spin-friendly surface. While the strategy raised eyebrows, veteran Sunil Gavaskar stepped in to defend the call, stating that the pitch was far from what critics labeled a “raging turner.”
India’s 30-run loss in Kolkata saw South African spinner Simon Harmer emerge as the game-changer, picking up a match haul of eight wickets. The Indian batting unit, however, struggled to adapt, failing to tackle the turning ball effectively, which ultimately led to their unexpected collapse.
“It was not a vicious turner,” Sunil Gavaskar clarified to India Today. “This was a pitch where you needed to bat like it was a five-day Test. Not like an ODI or T20, trying rescue shots after three dot balls. With the kind of batting lineup India had, 124 should have been chased down comfortably, with at least five wickets in hand.”
ALSO READ: Mitchell Starc Reveals Injury Chaos As Smith Pulls Hazlewood and Abbott From Shield Game
He also praised Harmer’s skillful control, pointing out that despite the spin-friendly conditions, it was the bowler’s intelligent variation that made the difference. “How many balls per over were turning sharply? He bowled straight, mixed it up, and got just enough assistance when needed,” Gavaskar observed.
Post-match, Gambhir doubled down on the team’s pitch request but admitted that India’s batters lacked application. He reiterated that the target was “very much within reach,” adding that failure to play with patience and solid technique was the real reason behind the loss.
WATCH – Steve Smith Picks His “Perfect Cricketer” Combining Kohli, Root, Maxwell, and More
“The point is, you should know how to play spin,” Gautam Gambhir stated. “This is the wicket we asked for. The curator did a good job. 123 was chaseable, provided you had the discipline, defensive technique, and temperament for it. It wasn’t a pitch for big strokes, but one where you could score by putting your head down and showing grit.”
The result has sparked debates not just about pitch preparations, but also about the modern Indian batting mindset when facing quality spin—especially at home.
