Former India batter Manoj Tiwary has launched a sharp critique of the process that led to Rohit Sharma’s removal as ODI captain, arguing the decision didn’t happen in a vacuum and pointing a finger at both chief selector Ajit Agarkar and head coach Gautam Gambhir. Tiwary called the move “disrespectful” to Rohit — a player who led India to the 2025 Champions Trophy — and questioned the cricketing logic behind sidelining a skipper of his stature.

Rohit’s last match as ODI captain was the Champions Trophy final in 2025, a tournament he won at the helm and thereby joined an elite list of Indian captains with multiple ICC titles. Yet, in a move that surprised many, the board opted for a fresh direction and handed leadership to Shubman Gill, a youthful choice aimed at long-term planning. Tiwary, however, is unconvinced that the change was justified purely on cricketing grounds.

“Ajit Agarkar is a decisive personality and unlikely to take such a step alone,” the former cricketer told Sports Today. “If a major leadership change is made, the coach’s input has to be part of it. You can’t have a selector announce a new captain without the coach backing it.”

ALSO READ: Damien Martyn Begins Next Phase Of Recovery After Remarkable Battle With Meningitis

In short, Manoj Tiwary called for accountability at both ends of the chain — saying Gambhir should take responsibility rather than remain in the background.

Central to Tiwary’s criticism is the implied doubt cast on Rohit’s batting and leadership credentials. He questioned why decision-makers seemed unconvinced about Rohit’s place in India’s 2027 World Cup plans, pointing out the veteran’s proven track record — including multiple double centuries and match-winning innings. “Doubting Rohit’s ability was a big mistake,” Tiwary argued, adding that removing him from captaincy felt devoid of cricketing logic.

Beyond the specifics of selection, Manoj Tiwary bemoaned the loss of clarity and the swirl of controversy that followed the change. For fans and former players alike, abrupt leadership swaps carry consequences: unsettled dressing rooms, divided public opinion, and the risk of undermining a player’s confidence.

ALSO READ: Mohammad Kaif Questions Jadeja’s Place, Backs Axar Patel As India’s Better ODI All-Rounder

Whether one agrees with Tiwary or not, his comments strike at a broader truth about elite sport: authority and accountability must be transparent. If India’s selection committee and coaching staff truly believe a generational shift was necessary, the rationale should be communicated clearly and respectfully — not framed in a way that leaves cricketing legends and their supporters searching for answers.