Karun Nair’s long-awaited return to the Indian Test side after eight years has not quite gone to script. Selected for the prestigious Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy, the Vidarbha batter was backed to bring experience and stability to the middle order. But three Tests in, Nair is yet to produce the kind of performance that once earned him a place in Indian cricket’s elite.

His comeback began on a sour note with a first-innings duck at Headingley. Since then, Nair has looked more assured at the crease, displaying glimpses of his trademark composure and timing. Yet, the scores haven’t reflected his potential. His best so far remains a fighting 40 in the first innings at Lord’s — a knock that showed promise before Ben Stokes dismissed him with a sharp delivery, and Joe Root held a blinder in the slips.
WATCH – Anderson Phillip’s Spectacular Catch Sends Travis Head Packing in Third Test Thriller
In the fourth innings at Lord’s, India were chasing 193 in fading light to take a 2-1 series lead. With Jaiswal falling early to Archer, Nair walked in alongside KL Rahul and looked compact. However, with just minutes to Stumps, he misjudged a delivery from Brydon Carse that came in with the angle. He offered no shot, was struck on the back pad, and after a short chat with Rahul, chose not to review.
Replays confirmed it was crashing into off-stump — another soft end to a promising start. Karun Nair’s 14 off 33 added to a string of underwhelming scores. With six innings now under his belt, pressure is mounting.
ALSO READ: India has solid batters in the dressing room: Washington Sundar confident of Lord’s win
Many fans are calling for the return of Sai Sudharsan, who was dropped after the first Test. As selection debates grow louder, one thing is clear — time is running out for Karun Nair to turn this comeback into a lasting revival.
Here’s how fans reacted to his second-innings dismissal at Lord’s:
Dear Cricket Never Give Him Chance @karun126 #INDvsENG
— Aanand Singh 🇮🇳🚩 (@AanandblasterXI) July 2, 2025
Karun Nair:- saar give me one more chance saar🤡🤡
It’s time to bring back young blood Sai Sudarshan….#INDvENG pic.twitter.com/Z9kuTvfJ4F
— Saurabh Praveen (@_SaurabhPraveen) July 13, 2025
Dear Cricket, don’t give him another chance
— muktisp (@muktipradhan) July 13, 2025
“Dear cricket don’t give him any single chance.” pic.twitter.com/yMl7J15ovF
— TruthSpreader🌟 (@NotJustARutuFan) July 13, 2025
Same looks
Same contribution
Same fatty
Same PR
Karun Nair make it sure we wouldn’t miss Rohit Sharma 🤡 pic.twitter.com/DCZSSHE1l9— BhaiSom33 (@HPstanno1) July 13, 2025
That was embarrassing… Yeahh that should be it for Karun Nair… pic.twitter.com/6CxfifDhGu
— Aashish🔰 (@Aashish_Shukla7) July 13, 2025
Dear cricket please give Sai Sudharsan a chance in place of Karun Nair 🙏 pic.twitter.com/u0Z25m9fGg
— 𝐀 (@Aagneyax) July 13, 2025
Karun Nair 🙆♂️🙆♂️ pic.twitter.com/vBQdwnc7Ip
— आशुतोष (@bakaitbaaz) July 13, 2025
Karun Nair in this Test series Vs England:
– 20(54).
– 31(50).
– 26(46).
– 40(62).
– 14(33).Karun Nair has start but he failed to convert those starts, Not a great return for him. pic.twitter.com/Ob9aqBgbhZ
— Tanuj (@ImTanujSingh) July 13, 2025
That was embarrassing… Yeahh that should be it for Karun Nair… pic.twitter.com/6CxfifDhGu
— Aashish🔰 (@Aashish_Shukla7) July 13, 2025
