Former India wicketkeeper and ex-selector Saba Karim has questioned the current selection committee’s decision, led by Ajit Agarkar, to include Rohit Sharma in the squad for the upcoming Australia tour. According to Karim, if Rohit is not captaining the ODI side, it indicates that the selectors do not view him as part of India’s long-term plans for the 2027 ODI World Cup.

He emphasised the need for clarity and consistency in the team’s roadmap leading up to the marquee event. Saba Karim, who has also served as the BCCI General Manager of Cricket Operations, didn’t mince words while pointing out what he considers a lack of strategic direction in India’s selection policies. He urged the selectors to define Rohit’s role clearly instead of making half-hearted decisions.

ALSO READ: Mohammed Siraj Reveals Priceless Advice From MS Dhoni That Changed His Career

“Why are you keeping him in the team? If he isn’t the captain, then it’s clear that you don’t see him playing the 2027 World Cup,” Saba Karim remarked. “If you don’t believe a player will be part of your World Cup plans, then it makes no sense to keep him in the setup.”

His comments come after India’s ODI captaincy transition, where Shubman Gill was appointed to lead the side. Ajit Agarkar explained that the move was part of a long-term vision, allowing Gill ample time to develop as a leader before the 2027 World Cup, which will be hosted across South Africa, Zimbabwe, and Namibia.

Saba Karim also cited India’s packed schedule and the challenge of managing three captains across formats as primary considerations behind the change. Despite the debate, Rohit Sharma’s leadership credentials remain unparalleled in Indian cricket.

ALSO READ: Mohammed Siraj Opens Up On Online Trolls, Mental Strength, and His Remarkable Comeback

He is the only captain besides MS Dhoni to guide India to three ICC white-ball finals, including victories in the T20 World Cup and Champions Trophy, and a runner-up finish in the ODI World Cup. Yet, as India plans for the future, Karim believes the selectors must strike a balance between respecting experience and committing to long-term goals.