Former Australian captain Greg Chappell has questioned England’s much-hyped ‘Bazball’ philosophy following their dramatic 2-2 Test series draw against India, arguing that “positive cricket” shouldn’t be confused with recklessness. Writing in his column for ESPNcricinfo, Chappell was full of praise for India’s young side, commending their resilience and tactical awareness, while warning England that flashy strokeplay won’t always win matches, especially in the red-ball format.

At the heart of Greg Chappell’s critique was Harry Brook, a batter known for his aggressive flair. “Brook is gifted—he has time, range, and elegance,” Chappell wrote. “But Test cricket is not about aesthetics alone. It’s about judgment. Knowing when to attack and when to grind it out.”

Chappell’s comments come in the wake of Brook’s crucial dismissal during the fifth Test at The Oval. England were comfortably placed at 301/3 chasing 374, but Brook’s rash shot triggered a collapse that saw them lose by six runs, allowing India to level the series 2-2.

ALSO READ: Mohammed Siraj Achieves Career-Best ICC Test Ranking After Oval Heroics

“The Bazball mindset brought energy back to English Test cricket, but it’s teetering on the edge of irresponsibility,” Greg Chappell warned. “All England needed was one batter to absorb pressure. Instead, Brook went for a glory shot and threw it away.”

While Greg Chappell acknowledged that Brook is still evolving, he urged the youngster to find the balance between flair and fight. “Joe Root didn’t become England’s highest run-scorer by just playing highlight-reel shots. He earned it with discipline and grit. Brook must embrace the grind too.”

On the broader picture, Chappell reflected on what made this series so memorable. He highlighted not just the close finishes but also the emotional and physical intensity that unfolded over five gripping Tests. Injured stars like Rishabh Pant and Chris Woakes became gladiators, pushing their limits to keep their teams in the fight.

“The subplots, the emotional rollercoasters, the shifting strategies—it was a series of soul and character. But it was India who walked away with a stronger identity and clearer purpose,” Greg Chappell concluded.

ALSO READ: Rishabh Pant’s Generosity Fulfils Karnataka Girl’s BCA Dream With Timely Financial Aid

As the cricketing world continues to dissect the outcome, Chappell’s insights add weight to the ongoing debate: Is Bazball sustainable in the long run, or will moments like these force England to recalibrate their fearless approach?