Former India player Saba Karim has criticised Ishan Kishan’s dismissal in the opening T20I against England, saying the wicketkeeper-batter essentially “pressed the self-destruct button” with a needless run-out. According to Karim, Kishan was largely responsible for his own dismissal after setting off for a nonexistent single in Durham on Wednesday, July 1.

Kishan was run out for a two-ball duck as India were building their innings against England, eventually posting a target of 190. However, rain denied the home side a chance to chase, and the match ended in a draw. Speaking on JioHotstar, Saba Karim said there was only a slim possibility of a successful run if Abhishek Sharma had reacted instantly to Kishan’s call. In his view, both batters lost awareness of the situation and failed to keep proper track of each other.

“It was self-destruction. Both Abhishek Sharma and Ishan Kishan were watching the ball. They should have been looking at each other. There might have been a possibility had Abhishek Sharma responded very quickly, but normally, the non-striker waits for the ball to beat the fielder in the infield, and he runs after that only,” he said.

Karim further felt that even if Abhishek had attempted the run, Jos Buttler’s sharp work behind the stumps would likely have made the dismissal unavoidable. He also pointed out that this was not the first such communication lapse involving Kishan in recent matches.

ALSO READ: Vaibhav Sooryavanshi’s India Debut Delay Will Add Pressure, Says Sunil Gavaskar

“In my opinion, there was no run there. Even if Abhishek Sharma had tried, it would have been difficult for him to reach the other end because Jos Buttler did an excellent job. He came to the stumps very quickly. Both batters need to work on their communication. It happened in Ireland and here as well,” Saba Karim added.

Kishan was sent back by Abhishek Sharma, but Harry Brook’s throw to Buttler found the batter short of his crease. The dismissal also echoed his run-out in the second T20I against Ireland, where he was involved in another mix-up, this time with Tilak Varma.

Former India all-rounder Irfan Pathan also agreed that Kishan took a risky call by going for a run that was never really on. On the same discussion, Pathan said Abhishek would also have been in trouble if he had responded positively to the call.

“There was no run at all. You would have heard Abhishek saying that he should have allowed the ball to pass the midwicket fielder, and then the mid-on fielder also wasn’t standing on the 30-yard circle. He was standing slightly ahead. When that happens, he is also attacking the ball,” he said.

ALSO READ: Shah Rukh Khan Opens KKR Cricket Stadium in California For LA 2028 Games

Pathan added that Kishan’s decision was simply the wrong one at the wrong time. “You played the ball softly. You have to take the run only after the ball passes the fielder who is trying to cut the ball. In my opinion, there was no run. I totally agree with Saba bhai. Abhishek would have gotten run out. It means you took a high-risk run, and when you do that, someone will be sacrificed. You got run out yourself. So it was a wrong decision from Ishan Kishan,” Irfan Pathan observed.

India were reduced to 6 for 2 after Kishan’s dismissal, but Abhishek Sharma’s explosive 59 off 24 balls and Shreyas Iyer’s composed 68 off 47 pulled the innings back. Shivam Dube then finished strongly with an unbeaten 42 off 21 to give India a competitive total.