The recent IPL 2024 clash between Punjab Kings (PBKS) and Mumbai Indians (MI) sparked controversy due to a disputed third umpire decision, reigniting discussions about the necessity of specialized officials in this role to enhance decision-making accuracy. The contentious incident unfolded during MI batter Suryakumar Yadav’s innings when a delivery from PBKS bowler Arshdeep Singh was not called a wide by the on-field umpire.
However, MI’s dugout, including Tim David, Kieron Pollard, and Mark Boucher, was seen on TV signaling for a review after observing the ball passing the wide guideline. Despite PBKS captain Sam Curran alerting the umpires about the attempted review from outside the playing area, the decision was referred to third umpire Nitin Menon. To the surprise of many, Menon overturned the original call after reviewing replays, classifying it as a wide delivery.
another incident where umpires supported MI. Tim David singling for DRS after seeing the reply, Sam Curran pointed out but umpire ignored him and asked from third umpire. this is shameful pic.twitter.com/QOS27aLXsr
— Sunil the Cricketer (@1sInto2s) April 19, 2024
This contentious reversal adds to a string of disputed decisions involving third umpires this IPL season, prompting former Australian cricketer Tom Moody to advocate for dedicated specialist third umpires. Moody emphasized the need for officials with experience and a specific skill set suited for the third umpire role.
ALSO READ: Hardik Pandya Fined Heavily by BCCI For Slow Over Rate In IPL 2024 Clash
In his tweet Tom Moody wrote: “”It’s time we considered having specialist 3rd umpires, too many questionable decisions are being made. Some umpires are better suited on the field, the 3rd umpire requires experience and a certain skill set.”
It’s time we considered having specialist 3rd umpires, too many questionable decisions being made.
Some umpires are better suited on field, the 3rd umpire requires experience and a certain skill set. #IPL— Tom Moody (@TomMoodyCricket) April 18, 2024
His remarks underscore the critical role of the third umpire, equipped with television replays and technology like ball-tracking, in making accurate decisions, especially in high-stakes matches where outcomes often hinge on tight calls.
WATCH – Rocky Flintoff’s Unbeaten Fifty Guides Lancashire To Draw Against Durham
Shifting focus to the match itself, MI, batting first, posted a formidable total of 192/7 with a stellar performance from Suryakumar Yadav (78 off 53) and Rohit Sharma (36 off 25). In response, PBKS faced a dismal start and were struggling at 77/6.
Although a late surge from Ashutosh Sharma (61 off 28) and Shashank Singh (41 off 25) provided a glimmer of hope, PBKS fell short of the target by nine runs. Notably, Jasprit Bumrah and Gerald Coetzee claimed six wickets collectively, contributing to MI’s victory.
