In their clash against Lucknow Super Giants, Mumbai Indians got off to a blazing start, reaching a score of 98/2 in the first 10 overs, laying a solid foundation for their power-hitting finishers. However, a couple of wickets in the 11th over brought Tim David to the crease earlier than expected. The Australian batsman had the opportunity to play substantial innings, but an umpiring decision in the 17th over prevented him from doing so, stirring controversy.
On the third ball of the 17th over bowled by Yash Thakur, a high full toss cross-seam delivery prompted David to go for a slog. Unfortunately, he failed to connect cleanly, and Deepak Hooda, stationed at long-on, completed the catch to dismiss the key wicket. However, David remained at the crease, assuming the ball was above waist height and thus should have been called a no-ball.
To the surprise of David and the Mumbai Indians camp, the third umpire Chris Gaffaney disagreed. The hawk-eye replay showed that the ball was marginally below David’s waist, leading Gaffaney to advise the on-field umpires Bruce Oxenford and Virender Sharma not to overturn the decision.
WATCH – Deepak Hooda Takes A Diving Catch To Send Back Tilak Verma
David, who had scored 13 runs off 13 balls, expressed his dissatisfaction with the decision and engaged in a brief discussion with Oxenford before making his way back to the pavilion. Following the dismissal, further controversy arose when side-angle photos suggested that the hawk-eye recreation may not have been entirely accurate, adding fuel to the debate surrounding the decision.
Here is the video of the dismissal of Tim David:
Yash Thakur with the big breakthrough! 🙌
The dangerous Tim David departs for 13.
Mumbai Indians 158/5 with less than 3 overs to go
Follow the match ▶️ https://t.co/CVo5K1wG31#TATAIPL | #Eliminator | #LSGvMI pic.twitter.com/slSvqWl2ge
— IndianPremierLeague (@IPL) May 24, 2023
Lucknow Super Giants (Playing XI): Ayush Badoni, Deepak Hooda, Prerak Mankad, Marcus Stoinis, Nicholas Pooran (wk), Krunal Pandya (c), Krishnappa Gowtham, Ravi Bishnoi, Naveen-ul-Haq, Yash Thakur, Mohsin Khan
WATCH – Naveen Ul Haq Churns Out Crowd Shutting Celebration After Dismissing Rohit Sharma
Mumbai Indians (Playing XI): Rohit Sharma (c), Ishan Kishan (wk), Cameron Green, Suryakumar Yadav, Tim David, Tilak Varma, Chris Jordan, Hrithik Shokeen, Piyush Chawla, Jason Behrendorff, Akash Madhwal
While some of the netizens advocated for the technology, others thought the decision was justified.
Tim David unhappy over No Ball decision by umpire. He stayed on the ground even after umpire declared it a ball. #LSGvsMI #MIvsLSG pic.twitter.com/ZAmQjRU1s0
— Silly Context (@sillycontext) May 24, 2023
Fair enough to understand the disappointment of Tim David as at the point of contact the height of the ball is waist high / above and the batsmen was in upright stance. The ball projection further dipping down to hit the stumps doesn’t really matter.
— Prasanna (@prasannalara) May 24, 2023
Tim David Out 🙄 pic.twitter.com/OfcbeRfpNm
— Lokesh Ramisetty (@lokesh_ramsetty) May 24, 2023
Someone needs to talk about this ball tracking technology man ! At least to me it looks highly incorrect.
Instead of checking the ball's meeting point where batsman meeting it & whether that's above waist, they r checking entire ball trajectory. Tim David looked NOT OUT to me pic.twitter.com/iPSbb8XyMm
— Shantanu 🏏🎧 (@Shantanu630) May 24, 2023
Poor umpiring https://t.co/Z0MwevN5ul
— गरीबदास गांडू (@Elclasicoipl20) May 24, 2023
Totally disappointed with the Umpiring. This was a no ball clearly #TimDavid #Eliminator pic.twitter.com/KqWpZea99p
— Mumbai Indians FC (@MIPaltanFamily) May 24, 2023
It was clear no ball Tim David asking correct definitely wrong decision, wrong umpiring !!#MIvsLSG #MumbaiIndians pic.twitter.com/4rcC2k0jp8
— Yash k_335 (@335Yash) May 24, 2023
Tim David has every right to be unhappy. https://t.co/Ojc1vNh7Io
— Archith (@UtdArc) May 24, 2023
Just see the difference between actual ball height and trajectory shown by third umpire. . 🙄🙄 What a pathetic decision this was.. #IPLPlayOffs #MIvsLSG #LSGvsMI #NoBall #biasedumpiring #timdavid pic.twitter.com/6KgXB97oei
— ᴄʀɪᴄᴋᴇᴛ ʟᴏᴠᴇʀ🗨️ (@criclover451807) May 24, 2023
Yash Thakur with the big breakthrough! 🙌
The dangerous Tim David departs for 13.
Mumbai Indians 158/5 with less than 3 overs to go
Follow the match ▶️ https://t.co/CVo5K1wG31#TATAIPL | #Eliminator | #LSGvMI pic.twitter.com/slSvqWl2ge
— IndianPremierLeague (@IPL) May 24, 2023
